# Gemini 4 Hydrogen vs Claude Opus 5.5: 23% Cheaper, Slower Answers

> Opus 5.5 tokens cost 2.67x Hydrogen's, but Hydrogen writes more: the same 11 calls cost 23% less on it and took 1.76x as long. Opus tops out higher, 59 vs 54.

- URL: https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/gemini-4-hydrogen-vs-claude-opus-5-5
- Published: 2026-11-22
- Updated: 2026-11-22
- Author: LaoZhang AI Team (https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/about)
- Topic: Model Comparisons
- Tags: Gemini 4 Hydrogen, Claude Opus 5.5, Gemini API, Claude API, model comparison, API pricing

---
Gemini 4 Hydrogen (`gemini-4-hydrogen`) costs $1.50 per million input tokens and $7.50 per million output tokens, against $4 and $20 for Claude Opus 5.5 (`claude-opus-5-5`), so every Opus token costs 2.67 times as much. Per finished job the gap is far smaller, because Hydrogen spends many more tokens thinking. On November 18, 2026, the same 11 API calls (eight small coding, reasoning and summary tasks) cost $0.2213 on Hydrogen at its default thinking level and $0.2875 on Opus 5.5 at its default effort: 23% less, not the 63% the token prices suggest. Both models passed all 11 calls, and Opus returned its answer sooner on seven of the eight tasks.

So move input-heavy and routine API work, such as long documents, logs, summaries, extraction and code you can test, to `gemini-4-hydrogen` at thinking level `high`. At that level it scores 51 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index, against 48 for Opus at its default `medium`, as of November 22, 2026. Keep `claude-opus-5-5` where you need its ceiling or its speed to first answer: at `xhigh` or `max` it scores 57–59, while Hydrogen's best is 54, and Claude Code with Opus max leads Antigravity with Hydrogen xhigh 58.2 to 52.3 on Artificial Analysis's coding-agent index. For most teams the answer is to split the work by task, not to switch everything.

Two situations make the choice for you. With no budget, Hydrogen is the only option of the two: the Gemini API free tier charges nothing for it (Google uses free-tier data to improve its products), and the Gemini app offers it to every user, while claude.ai Free has no Opus and paid Claude plans start at $20 a month. In Russia, mainland China and Hong Kong, Claude isn't offered at all. The "about a third of the cost" and "20x cheaper" figures you may have seen come from particular pairings and from long agent sessions, where Hydrogen does get much cheaper and faster but also scores lower.

## Hydrogen or Opus 5.5? Switch input-heavy jobs, keep hard agent work

Decide by the kind of work, not by the token price. Hydrogen's lower price wins clearly when a job is mostly input to read, or when the task is routine enough that its default level passes. Its advantage shrinks or reverses when a short question makes it think at length, and it never reaches Opus's top score. The table pairs each kind of work with a model, a starting level and the measurement behind it; the levels are explained in the section on which level to run.

| Your work | Start with | Level | What the choice rests on |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Long documents, logs, transcripts, extraction | `gemini-4-hydrogen` | `high` | Long-document summary at 0.39x of Opus's cost, 146 KB log at 0.76x (November 18, 2026) |
| Routine coding and API calls you can test | `gemini-4-hydrogen` | `high` | Cheaper on 7 of 8 tasks; 51 vs 48 on AA at 0.76x the cost per AA task |
| Short reasoning-heavy questions (math, logic puzzles) | `claude-opus-5-5` | `medium` | On the digit-sum task Hydrogen wrote 4.75x the output tokens and cost 1.76x |
| Chat, IDE help, anything where you wait for the reply | `claude-opus-5-5` | `medium` | Median call: Opus 9.6 s, Hydrogen 15.6 s; AA time to first answer token 14.44 s vs 22.05 s |
| Hardest multi-step coding agents | `claude-opus-5-5` | `xhigh` or `max` | Only Opus reaches 57–59; Claude Code + Opus max 58.2 vs Antigravity + Hydrogen xhigh 52.3 |
| Long agent sessions where a lower score is acceptable | `gemini-4-hydrogen` | `high`, `xhigh` if needed | Bito's test: 0.24x Opus's cost per session, about a third of the time, 9 points lower |
| No budget, video or audio input, or a region without Claude | `gemini-4-hydrogen` | `high` | Free API tier; video, audio and PDF input; Claude not offered in Russia or mainland China |

Splitting is cheap to set up because both models take a level parameter and a plain prompt. Route by task type, run each model on twenty or so of your own requests, and compare cost per accepted answer rather than cost per token. If Hydrogen at `high` fails where Opus `medium` passes, the retry erases the saving: on the tasks tested here, two Hydrogen attempts cost about 1.5 times one Opus call.

## Same 11 calls on November 18, 2026: both passed, Hydrogen cost 0.77x

On November 18, 2026, both models ran the same eight tasks through the laozhang.ai gateway with one API key, billed at Google's and Anthropic's list prices: a word problem, merge intervals, parsing a duration string, a top-k word count, a five-bullet summary of an ~11,000-token document (one sample each), and an expression evaluator, a CSV line splitter and a digit-sum reasoning question (two samples each). Every answer was graded against hidden tests or exact answers. Hydrogen ran at thinking level `high` (its default), Opus at effort `medium` (its default) and again at `high`.

*Disclosure: [laozhang.ai is our own service](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/about#laozhang). Its prices are platform pricing, not an independent comparison.*

| Configuration | Passed | Input tokens | Output tokens | Cost at list price | Summed call time | Median call |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Gemini 4 Hydrogen, thinking `high` (default) | 11/11 | 12,712 | 26,966, of which 21,565 thinking | $0.2213 | 205.9 s | 15.6 s |
| Claude Opus 5.5, effort `medium` (default) | 11/11 | 17,202 | 10,933 | $0.2875 | 116.9 s | 9.6 s |
| Claude Opus 5.5, effort `high` | 11/11 | 17,202 | 11,972 | $0.3083 | 126.4 s | 10.1 s |

Read the table as a measure of tokens, money and waiting time, not intelligence. The tasks were small and well specified, both models passed every one, and one or two samples per task can't separate them on quality; for capability, use the Artificial Analysis scores further down. Hydrogen cost 0.77x Opus medium and 0.72x Opus high, and its summed call time was 1.76x and 1.63x as long. The output column counts everything each model wrote, thinking included, because the gateway doesn't report Opus's thinking separately. Hydrogen's 80% thinking share is visible only on its own side.

The setup differed in two ways that matter for the time column. Hydrogen's calls used Google's native `generateContent` endpoint, non-streaming, four at a time, around 03:20 UTC; Opus's used `/v1/messages` with streaming, one after another, around 05:20 UTC. Per-call wall time is comparable, but route and time of day still differ. One Opus `high` answer split its code across files and passed only after a re-grade. Hydrogen also counted the same 11,000-token document as 11,110 input tokens where Opus counted 15,335, which is part of why Hydrogen spent less on input overall.

If you want both models behind one key, as in this test, [laozhang.ai](https://laozhang.ai/) returned `claude-opus-5-5` on all 24 Opus calls and `gemini-4-hydrogen` on all 11 Hydrogen calls at list price; its [API documentation](https://docs.laozhang.ai/en) covers both formats. Buying direct means the Gemini API (free or paid tier) for Hydrogen and the Anthropic API for Opus.

## Is Hydrogen a third of Opus 5.5's cost? Only at xhigh against max

No, not at the defaults. Hydrogen is 2.67x cheaper per token on every price line, but a job's cost is price times tokens, and Hydrogen writes more tokens. As of November 18, 2026, the [Gemini API pricing page](https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/pricing#gemini-4-hydrogen) lists Hydrogen at $1.50 input, $7.50 output (thinking included) and $0.075 cached input per million tokens, with Batch at $0.75 and $3.75; Anthropic's price list has Opus 5.5 at $4, $20 and $0.20 for cache reads, with Batch at $2 and $10. Hydrogen caches implicitly only, and neither model charges extra for long context across its 1M window.

You can redo the November 18 total yourself. Hydrogen's 12,712 input and 26,966 output tokens at Opus's prices would cost 12,712 × $4 + 26,966 × $20 per million, or $0.590, which is more than twice Opus's own $0.2875 for the same calls. Divide by 2.67 and you get Hydrogen's actual $0.2213. Writing 2.47x as many output tokens eats most of the per-token discount, which is why the measured saving is 23% rather than 63%. Calculations that assume both models write the same number of tokens, such as Aleksei Aleinikov's 10-turn session example on his blog, arrive at the full 2.67x saving for that reason.

![Opus 5.5 output tokens cost $20 per million against $7.50 for Hydrogen, but Hydrogen wrote 26,966 output tokens to Opus's 10,933, so the 11 calls cost $0.2213 against $0.2875](https://blog.laozhang.ai/posts/en/gemini-4-hydrogen-vs-claude-opus-5-5/img/token-price-vs-job-cost.webp)

Artificial Analysis's suite tells the same story. Its "cost per task" is the average cost of one task in its own benchmark suite, not your bill, but the ratio is useful: at each model's default, Hydrogen `high` costs $1.87 per task against $2.45 for Opus `medium`, or 0.76x, as of November 22, 2026. The "about a third" figure appears only when Hydrogen `xhigh` ($3.16) is set against Opus `max` ($10.04), a 0.31x ratio at which Opus scores 59 to Hydrogen's 54. No measured pair supports "20x cheaper".

The large gaps people post come from agent builds, not single requests. Instagram creator charliehills ran four identical builds, a motion showreel, a 3D airliner, a 3D White House and a café-racer bike, and reported $4.77 and about 45 minutes for Hydrogen against $15.09 and about 76 minutes for Opus; the creator also noted that Opus's airliner had 491 parts to Hydrogen's 152. That is one user's run with unstated levels, but it fits the agent pattern in the coding-agent section below.

## Per task: Hydrogen saved most on long input, cost more on digit-sum

Hydrogen was cheaper than Opus `medium` on seven of the eight tasks on November 18, 2026, and the saving depended on how much it chose to think. On the long-document summary it cost 0.39x, because input dominates that job and Hydrogen's input is both cheaper and counted as fewer tokens. On the digit-sum question it thought through 7,581 output tokens against Opus's 1,596 and cost 1.76x as much.

| Task (samples) | Hydrogen `high` | Opus 5.5 `medium` | Hydrogen ÷ Opus | Output tokens, Hydrogen / Opus | Seconds, Hydrogen / Opus |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Merge intervals (1) | $0.0051 | $0.0192 | 0.27x | 658 / 937 | 7.3 / 9.8 |
| Long-document summary (1) | $0.0355 | $0.0902 | 0.39x | 2,518 / 1,442 | 19.6 / 14.4 |
| Word problem (1) | $0.0093 | $0.0151 | 0.62x | 1,217 / 738 | 11.0 / 8.9 |
| Parse a duration string (1) | $0.0095 | $0.0145 | 0.66x | 1,225 / 675 | 12.7 / 7.5 |
| Top-k word frequency (1) | $0.0044 | $0.0058 | 0.76x | 555 / 253 | 7.9 / 4.5 |
| CSV line splitter (2) | $0.0306 | $0.0377 | 0.81x | 4,006 / 1,788 | 29.6 / 18.5 |
| Expression evaluator (2) | $0.0698 | $0.0726 | 0.96x | 9,206 / 3,504 | 64.9 / 34.9 |
| Digit-sum reasoning (2) | $0.0571 | $0.0325 | 1.76x | 7,581 / 1,596 | 52.9 / 18.4 |

![Bar chart of Hydrogen's cost as a multiple of Opus 5.5's on each of the eight tasks, from 0.27x on merge intervals to 1.76x on digit-sum reasoning, with output token counts beside each bar](https://blog.laozhang.ai/posts/en/gemini-4-hydrogen-vs-claude-opus-5-5/img/per-task-cost-ratio.webp)

The pattern is the useful part, not any single row. Thinking length varies from run to run: Hydrogen's merge-intervals answer used about 110 thinking tokens on November 18 and 1,763 on November 14, so a one-sample row can swing. What held across the set is that the more a task rewards long deliberation, the closer Hydrogen's bill gets to Opus's, and the longer you wait for it.

## A 146 KB log: Hydrogen $0.37 in 201 s, Opus 5.5 $0.48 in 60 s

Long input is where Hydrogen's lower input price should matter most, and it did, but less than you might expect. On November 18, 2026, each model got a 1,500-line, 146 KB application log in a single turn with no tools and was asked for seven exact numbers from it. Both got all seven right. Hydrogen at `high` read 79,312 input tokens, wrote 33,029 output tokens (32,948 of them thinking) and cost $0.3667; Opus at `medium` read 78,537 input tokens, wrote 8,351 and cost $0.4812. Opus at `high` also got all seven, in 57.0 s for $0.4752.

So Hydrogen cost 0.76x, but it took 201.2 s against Opus's 59.6 s, 3.4 times as long, and its first answer text arrived at 200.4 s. Here both models counted the log at about the same number of input tokens, so the whole difference came from Hydrogen thinking through almost four times as many output tokens. That would have overrun a 32,000-token output cap: if you send Hydrogen long inputs, leave room in `maxOutputTokens` (the default synchronous cap is 65,536). This was one sample at about 79K input tokens and says nothing about inputs near the 1M limit.

## Which is faster? Opus 5.5 answered sooner on 7 of 8 tasks

On single requests, Opus 5.5 is the faster model to wait for. In the November 18 test, Opus `medium` finished sooner on seven of the eight tasks, with a median call of 9.6 s against Hydrogen's 15.6 s, and it answered the 146 KB log in a third of Hydrogen's time. Artificial Analysis measures the same direction at the defaults as of November 22, 2026: 14.44 s to the first answer token for Opus `medium` against 22.05 s for Hydrogen `high`, and 6.7 against 9.1 minutes per task in its suite.

"Hydrogen is much faster" usually means one of two other things. Output-speed figures of roughly 170–198 tokens per second for Hydrogen against about 110–115 for Opus, credited to Bito AI, measure how fast tokens stream, and Hydrogen has more of them to stream before the answer, so you can see faster tokens and a later answer at the same time. The other meaning is time per agent session, covered in the next section. When the two models run at the same named level, `high` for both, Artificial Analysis puts them at 9.1 and 9.3 minutes per task, about even.

## Claude Code vs Antigravity: Opus max 58.2, Hydrogen xhigh 52.3

In agent work Hydrogen is much cheaper and faster per session, and Opus is clearly better. Artificial Analysis's Coding Agent Index tests each model inside its maker's own agent, so it compares "model plus agent" rather than two models in one harness. As of November 19, 2026, Claude Code with Opus 5.5 at `max` scored 58.2 at $12.61 and 65.3 minutes per task, and Antigravity CLI with Hydrogen at `xhigh` scored 52.3 at 32.1 minutes per task with about 405 steps; Artificial Analysis doesn't list a per-task dollar figure for the Hydrogen run, so no cost ratio is given here.

Bito AI's own test, published November 13, 2026, explains how agent users and single-request tests reach opposite impressions. On one-shot questions about a codebase, Bito scored the two as a tie (87.4% for Hydrogen, 87.5% for Opus) at $0.30 against $0.37 per question, 0.81x, with Hydrogen taking about two minutes per answer where Claude models usually took a minute or less. That matches the direction of the November 18 calls: slightly cheaper, slower to answer. In long multi-turn sessions on production services, though, Hydrogen averaged $4.37 per session against Opus's $18.38 (0.24x) and finished in about a third of the time, 6.9 against 19 minutes on hard 5-turn sessions and 38.5 against 112 minutes on a 20-turn session. Its overall score was 77.6% against 86.9%, it made about 0.8 misleading claims per answer against 0.3 for Opus on the hard sessions, and most of its loss on the 20-turn session came from four turns: the opening investigation, a mid-session change of requirements, PR descriptions and an on-call runbook. Bito sells a model router, so it has an interest in routing work to cheaper models, and the levels it used weren't stated.

If your agent work is long and you review the output anyway, Hydrogen can cut the bill to around a quarter. If the agent's first answer needs to be right, especially when requirements change mid-task, Opus is the one that held up in both of these tests. Using Hydrogen in Antigravity requires a paid Google AI Pro or Ultra plan; Opus in Claude Code requires a paid Claude plan or API key.

## Is Gemini better than Claude Opus? Opus 5.5 scores 59, Hydrogen 54

Claude Opus 5.5 scores higher at its top settings, and Hydrogen matches or beats it only when Opus runs at a lower level. On the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1, as of November 22, 2026, Opus reaches 59 at `max` and 57 at `xhigh`; Hydrogen's best is 54 at `xhigh`. At the defaults the order flips, with Hydrogen `high` at 51 against Opus `medium` at 48, because Opus's default is a mid level on its five-step scale.

| Model and level | AA Intelligence Index | Cost per AA task | Time per AA task | Time to first answer token |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Opus 5.5 `max` | 59 | $10.04 | 25.3 min | 345.44 s |
| Opus 5.5 `xhigh` | 57 | $6.05 | 15.9 min | 69.11 s |
| Hydrogen `xhigh` | 54 | $3.16 | 16.9 min | 55.24 s |
| Opus 5.5 `high` | 52 | $3.46 | 9.3 min | 24.37 s |
| Hydrogen `high` (default) | 51 | $1.87 | 9.1 min | 22.05 s |
| Opus 5.5 `medium` (default) | 48 | $2.45 | 6.7 min | 14.44 s |
| Hydrogen `medium` | 41 | $0.80 | 3.9 min | 13.12 s |
| Opus 5.5 `low` | 35 | $0.98 | 3.1 min | 5.64 s |
| Hydrogen `low` | 27 | $0.29 | 1.5 min | 7.91 s |

Source: the [Artificial Analysis Gemini 4 Hydrogen vs Claude Opus 5.5 comparison](https://artificialanalysis.ai/models/comparisons/gemini-4-hydrogen-vs-claude-opus-5-5), which re-measures over time; Hydrogen's time per task at `high` was 8.4 minutes on November 18 and 9.1 on November 22. Opus's rows carry the label "Default Fallback" on that page.

The overall index hides a split by field. On Artificial Analysis's Finance & Accounting and Legal indexes, Hydrogen `xhigh` scores 58 and 57, above Opus `xhigh` at 56 and 55; on Strategy & Ops and Healthcare & Medical, Opus `xhigh` stays ahead (59 vs 58, 56 vs 53). The overall index also counts coding and terminal benchmarks that these field indexes leave out, so a lead on documents doesn't carry over to coding, where the agent results above favor Opus. For document-heavy analysis Hydrogen `xhigh` is a serious alternative to Opus `xhigh` at about half the cost per task, while for coding the ceiling difference is real.

## Which level to run: Hydrogen high, Opus 5.5 medium or high

Run Hydrogen at `high`, its default, and treat `medium` as a different, weaker model. The two scales don't line up: Hydrogen has four thinking levels (`low`, `medium`, `high`, `xhigh`, default `high`), Opus has five effort levels (`low`, `medium`, `high`, `xhigh`, `max`, default `medium`). "Each at its default" is a fair comparison; "both at high" is two different settings that happen to share a name.

On Artificial Analysis's numbers, dropping Hydrogen from `high` to `medium` cuts the cost per task from $1.87 to $0.80 but loses 10 points (51 to 41), so only do it for work you've checked passes. The closest score match is Hydrogen `high` (51) against Opus `high` (52), where Hydrogen costs 0.54x at about the same time per task; that's the fairest pairing if you currently run Opus at `high`. If you need more than 54, there is no Hydrogen setting for it, and Opus `xhigh` (57) is the step up. At the cheap end, Hydrogen `medium` scores 41 at $0.80 against Opus `low` at 35 and $0.98.

The parameters, as used in the November 18 test:

```jsonc
// Gemini API, generateContent
{
  "generationConfig": {
    "thinkingConfig": { "thinkingLevel": "high" },
    "maxOutputTokens": 65536
  }
}
```

```jsonc
// Anthropic Messages API
{
  "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
  "max_tokens": 32000,
  "thinking": { "type": "adaptive" },
  "output_config": { "effort": "medium" }
}
```

Hydrogen doesn't accept `minimal`, and Opus 5.5 returns a 400 error if you send `thinking: {"type": "disabled"}` at any effort. Set `thinking` explicitly on Opus as shown: through the laozhang.ai gateway, omitting it returned no thinking blocks on Sonnet 5.5 in October 2026. Google's [Gemini thinking guide](https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/thinking) and Anthropic's [effort documentation](https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/build-with-claude/effort) list the levels.

*Disclosure: [laozhang.ai is our own service](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/about#laozhang). Its prices are platform pricing, not an independent comparison.*

## Free and paid access: Hydrogen has a free tier, Opus needs Pro

Hydrogen is free to try in several places and Opus in none. Hydrogen has been generally available since November 12, 2026, on both the free and paid tiers of the Gemini API, and it's in the Gemini app's model picker for all users. Opus 5.5 has no API free tier, and claude.ai Free includes neither Opus nor Claude Code. More on each: [Gemini 4 Hydrogen Pricing: API Cost per Call by Thinking Level](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/gemini-4-hydrogen-api-pricing) and [How to Access Claude Opus 5.5: 6 Ways In, Which Free Routes Work](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/how-to-access-claude-opus-5-5).

| Where | Gemini 4 Hydrogen | Claude Opus 5.5 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| API free tier | Yes, input and output free; Google uses the data to improve its products | None |
| Apps | Gemini app model picker, all users; AI Studio free and paid | Claude Pro $20 a month ($17 billed annually), Max $100, Ultra $200, Team, Enterprise |
| Coding agent | Antigravity with paid Google AI Pro or Ultra | Claude Code on paid plans and the API (default model); GitHub Copilot Pro+, Max, Business, Enterprise |
| Inputs | Text, image, video, audio, PDF | Text, image |

On a zero budget, start with Hydrogen on the Gemini API free tier and keep anything confidential off it, since free-tier prompts can be used by Google while paid-tier data isn't. For Opus, Claude's supported-countries list doesn't include Russia, mainland China or Hong Kong, and that also applies to cloud platforms and authorized resellers.

## Hydrogen vs Sonnet 5.5, GPT-6.2 Sol, and Carbon or Neon vs Opus

If you want to stay with Anthropic but pay less, compare one step down first in [Claude Sonnet 5.5 vs Opus 5.5: When Half the Price Really Saves](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/claude-sonnet-5-5-vs-opus-5-5); Hydrogen against Sonnet on the same task set is in [Claude Sonnet 5.5 vs Gemini 3.8 Flash, 4 Hydrogen: Cost per Task](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/claude-sonnet-5-5-vs-gemini-3-8-flash). Hydrogen against OpenAI's everyday model is in [Gemini 4 Hydrogen vs GPT-6.2 Sol: Cheaper Tokens, 3.6x the Cost](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/gemini-4-hydrogen-vs-gpt-6-2-sol). If you're weighing Google's stronger models against Opus instead, see [Gemini 4 Carbon vs Opus 5.5: Opus Still Wins Coding Agents](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/gemini-4-carbon-vs-claude-opus-5-5) and [Gemini 4 Neon vs Opus 5.5 vs GPT-6.2 Sol: Cost at Equal Score](https://blog.laozhang.ai/en/posts/gemini-4-neon-vs-gpt-6-2-sol-vs-claude-opus-5-5).

## Sources

External pages this guide links to, in the order they appear. Last updated 2026-11-22.

- [Gemini API pricing page](https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/pricing) (ai.google.dev)
- [Artificial Analysis Gemini 4 Hydrogen vs Claude Opus 5.5 comparison](https://artificialanalysis.ai/models/comparisons/gemini-4-hydrogen-vs-claude-opus-5-5) (artificialanalysis.ai)
- [Gemini thinking guide](https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/thinking) (ai.google.dev)
- [effort documentation](https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/build-with-claude/effort) (platform.claude.com)
